Free
Try transcription and use the browser tools for occasional tasks.
$0
No credit card required
- 20 transcription minutes in total
- Edit and export your transcripts
- 2 uses per day on each eligible media tool
20 transcription minutes total with a free account
No credit card required
Transcribe files such as MP3, WAV, MP4, and MOV.
Detect the language or choose Accurate or Universal mode.
Translate a finished transcript into another language.
Trim to a segment. Batch up to 10 files with the Full plan.
Add terms, keep filler words, or mask profanity where supported.
Jump to a line’s timestamp and replay the recording.
Correct transcript text, find phrases, and save to folders.
Download TXT, DOCX, PDF, SRT, or VTT.
Draft newsletters, X posts, and threads from a transcript.
Extract audio from video or convert to another audio format.
Reduce noise, split, merge, or compress audio. Adjust speed or pitch.
Convert supported SRT, VTT, ASS, SBV, and TXT files.
Use speaker labels to see who said what. When you need to verify a quote, use its timestamp to find the same moment in the recording.
Follow a real interview with two speakers. Select any timestamp to hear that part of the recording.
Create a free accountWelcome, everyone. Today we are meeting with Alek Tarkowski, Director of Strategy at the Open Future Foundation, a European think tank for the open movement. He is a sociologist an activist and a strategist, active for a long time in social movements. He is also on the board at Creative Commons. Welcome, Alek. Thank you for giving time to us.
Hello, Stefano. Thank you for the invitation.
Let’s start talking about the artificial intelligence, how it’s affecting common life. How are these applications that you see being deployed into society? How is that affecting real-life people?
We live certainly at an interesting time, a time of technological change, which probably has been the case for as long as I’m an adult, for 30 years, but there is a sense of there’s something new, right, that these so-called AI technologies are really different from the previous waves of internet technologies.
Now, I think the interesting thing is that you said we can see them. Actually, I think the trick is that in many cases, we do not see them. There’s a lot of also confusion, what is in AI technology, and what — and there’s some also confusion between what is already happening and what we’re expecting to happen, which I think is typical of these emergent technologies. They function somewhere between fiction, prototype, deployment, and mainstream, right? That’s the curve they’re on.
Some magic here and there.
There’s a lot of magic and a lot of people like to sprinkle a lot more magic than there is. I also like a term that’s sometimes used alternatively to artificial intelligence, which is automated decision-making. It sounds a bit technical, it of course, means something different. I think it’s a nice term to deploy. Basically, automated decision-making says there are situations where humans no longer decide about you, that there are some systems that do that. In this situation, let’s say were traditionally some bureaucrat in the city would decide maybe which school your child will go to or whether you are eligible for some social support. More and more often, this will be done by automated systems, of which artificial intelligence systems are one specific category.
Yeah. It’s really fantastic how that term conveys very clearly what are we talking about. We’re talking about AI system that is making decisions for you. It’s really clear, rather than the magic.
Yeah. I like it, because it also connects this conversation to the futuristic conversation or the on AI with issues were already aware of. There are many situations where you don’t need advanced technologies, but still decisions are made, not by humans. There are some cases in Poland where for instance, decisions about providing unemployment benefits was made by what was dubbed the automated system. There was even a big investigation made by the Panopticon Foundation. They discovered that the system is actually an algorithm that can be described in a spreadsheet.
It was a really super simple system. It gathered input in the shape of 10 questions. The public official asks the person applying for the benefits and turned out some very basic functions to say yes or no. The question was, so is this okay, because there wasn’t really any AI hiding inside? There was suspicion that there is, but it wasn’t confirmed. I think the answer was, yes, it’s still an issue. More importantly, more and more often, these systems are actually AI-powered, right? There is some component of machine learning happening inside. We should probably expect that in the coming years, there’ll be more and more such systems.
Yeah. You introduce a very important piece there where you discover that the system in Poland for unemployment actually had a very simple algorithm that could inspect and was easy to understand and maybe even fix to spot unfairness or mistakes with proper AI systems that are really not available. It’s one of those obscurities that inside neural networks especially, are hard to diagnose or hard to investigate in order to predict their outcomes, too. In this case, it’s we have real life being impacted by automated decision-making. How are regulators approaching this issue? Do they know? Are they noticing?
At least in Europe, they do. I think it’s a good time to do it, because I believe that these AI systems are not yet deployed on mass. You make a valid point. That’s the big challenge with them. The issues are the same as with all the automation, but the ways of addressing them are a lot more harder, because there’s this, I think, beautiful symbol of the black box, right? That hides things inside. That’s exactly the case with their system. Their complexity basically makes them much harder to analyze, assess their impact, and so on.
I participated in a study done by AlgorithmWatch, a German Foundation, called Automating Society, which looked at cases of the deployment of such AI systems in Europe. To be honest, there are too many, yet at least ones that are publicly known. Here, a caveat is probably needed. You don’t find them if you look, let’s say in cities, in small companies, in a national government, but obviously, then there are these huge platforms, which we know are extensively and more and more employing machine learning mechanisms, but in a way that is not really clear. We all use search engines that by now are so almost certainly AI-powered.
We use social networks that filter content, most probably with AI technologies. Again, the black box appears, there’s no certainty. It’s a bit of a weird moment, you can both say, “No, I don’t really see these technologies around me.” You can probably be just as correct in saying, “Hey, they’re everywhere. Any app you choose in your phone, they might be there.”
Right, exactly. I mean, from routing and orienting through the streets of an unknown city calling a cab. I’ve always wondered how much of my decisions to walk through a street or drive through a street were driven by advertisers at some point. The doubts remain because we really don’t know from the outside. There is no label applied to this application to say this is being influenced by this and that.
So you mentioned that the European Union seems to be extremely active on the AI front and they published the AI Act. Can you give us a little bit of an overview of what that is or what stage it is?
The AI Act proposal was published last year, as one in a series of several regulatory measures which is really a big European regulatory push on digital, right? We have the recently adopted Digital Markets Act and Digital Services Act, which regulate platforms. We have a whole package of data governance mechanism, which by the way, I think do connect with AI conversations. Then we have the AI Act. I mentioned this study Automating Society, which showed that there aren’t that many systems yet deployed, because I think it shows this is exactly the right moment to have a conversation about AI regulation.
I’m happy it’s happening right now because, as we know, policies are deployed more slowly than technology. You need to give them time. I think Europe by passing these laws is giving itself time. The question is, of course, what kind of regulation? Is it a good regulation? Let’s maybe briefly go over the document what it proposes basically, I think the key category, there is risk. Really Europe has been developing an approach they call Trustworthy AI. Then this approach, the biggest question for AI to be trustworthy is whether it is risky or not. The regulation doesn’t really cover all cases of AI. It really focuses on two issues. What kinds of AI uses or technologies are so dangerous that they should be outright banned? What technologies or context in which they are used are high risk? So are risky to an extent that you really need to regulate their use.
This is basically what this Act tries to do. In terms of the users that are banned. It’s a very short list. It includes subliminal distortion which is a bit almost science fiction sounding category, but really, and this is interesting with the regulator believes there are uses of AI that can subliminally affect humans and this should be banned. But then the more realistic ones are banned on social scoring and the mechanisms that usually are described as being deployed in China where as a citizen, you get scored on how good the person you are. These are meant to be banned in Europe.
Banned on real time biometric identification, so o basically technologies that take data from all the cameras deployed in urban spaces and that lets you identify people in the real-time. These are meant to be banned, although there are some carve-outs basically for public security. Then the last category is technologies that exploit vulnerabilities. So find some ways maybe to make elderly people do something against their wish, making use of the fact that they don’t understand technology. These really high-level risks. You can argue whether it’s a good list or not. I am happy that Europe is thinking about banning for instance, social scoring.
That’s very interesting. I wonder how it will be classified if you have a five stars as a customer.
Then you get discounted if that would fall into that category or if it’s just the scoring for the government that is prohibited. I understand that it’s mainly for the government and also this idea that you’re starting to combine sources. This is I think, the big risk that you have some five-star rating, how well you party in the club, which I could imagine happening. Then that data is shared with your employer and further on goes on to determine your, I don’t know, health portfolio, right? All these scenarios, I think, that the dangerous one, but really, when you say social scoring the problem is that then someone really gives you a score. There are some information that for instance, in China, they’re considering that the score could determine whether you get a passport for instance, right? Some basic rights are limited.
Yeah. I’ve seen similar experiments also starting in some cities in Italy, where they were scoring citizens about how well they were behaving in certain settings, so that they could get discounts on taxes like trash, disposal, and things like that. I don’t know how much of the AI was involved there, but in any case, very scary propositions.
I think the broader category is that of the high-risk situations in here, some things they’re considering our use of AI in the context of employment. All kinds of work-related HR decisions, uses in education and related to vocational issues. Scoring of students, how well they study, trying to determine who they will be uses in law enforcement, such as these ideas of predictive policy. There are some sorts of high-profile cases from the US where they attempted to use previous data on crimes and arrests to determine who will commit the crime again.
People seem to love this scenario because they come out of science fiction movies, but they really are rife with risks that affect basically basic rights of citizens, right? If a system deems you guilty, basically, before you commit a crime, I think that’s really serious. Another area that is high risk is migration. I live in Poland, where we just have the huge wave of refugees from Ukraine. I think this suddenly becomes very relevant. These are people, again, who are very vulnerable and their ideas how to deploy systems that can really be, basically inhuman. The last category is justice and democracy, again a very fundamental issue that you shouldn’t toy with democracy using AI technologies.
This is one part of the AI Act. It’s about the technologies that are too dangerous.
The whole question is, so what regulation do you introduce? The proposal comes with a list of some measures that includes basically if you want it to summarize it three things, impact assessments and monitoring of deployment of these systems, that they’re not left alone, that someone asks questions, what will happen if I introduce in a school system these technologies? Second thing is transparency. You mentioned labels. Am I aware that there’s an AI system there? Am I aware of its decisions? Can I be maybe told on what basis it made the decision?
The third category is human oversight. In what situations for instance, you might be able to ask, hello, I would this decision to be reviewed by a human, right? Instead of a machine. It of course, gets more complicated, but basically Europe is thinking that when a use of AI can be called high risk, these sorts of regulations start to apply. Of course, the huge debate that started immediately and has been running for the last year is whether these measures are sufficient. There’s of course, a group of people who say no, we need much harder protections of persons, basic rights. Of course, there’s another column that says these measures were curb innovation too much. There’s a now quite intense policy debate happening on this.
Start free. Upgrade for more transcription time or premium media tools.
Try transcription and use the browser tools for occasional tasks.
$0
No credit card required
For regular audio and video conversion, cleanup, and preparation.
$69 / year
$5.75/month equivalent, billed yearly
For ongoing transcription, premium tools, and writing from recordings.
$190 / year
$15.83/month equivalent, billed yearly
| Feature | Free | Tools | Full |
|---|---|---|---|
| Transcription allowance | 20 min total | 20 min total | 15 hr per 24 hr |
| Eligible media tool limits | 2 uses per tool per day | Premium access | Premium access |
| Eligible media file limits | 50 MiB and 15 min | Free-plan caps lifted | Free-plan caps lifted |
| Transcript editing and export | Included | Included | Included |
| Content Studio | Not included | Not included | Included |
A free account includes 20 minutes of transcription in total. You can edit and export your transcripts. The media tools have separate limits. See what each plan includes.
Yes. Choose the language when you add your recording, or let SCRIBERFLO detect it. See the supported languages.
You can import a video’s existing captions when it has a usable caption track. See how YouTube caption import works.
Yes. Edit the transcript in your workspace, then download TXT, DOCX, or PDF for reading and sharing, or SRT and VTT for timed subtitles.